Nexview Consulting - S&OP Consulting

  • About
    • Leadership
    • Vision, Mission, Values
    • Why Nexview?
  • Services
    • Overview
    • S&OP and Supply Chain Management
    • S&OP Readiness Assessment
    • S&OP Coaching
    • Training Courses
      • Training Overview
      • S&OP
      • Demand Planning
      • Combined Demand Planning and S&OP
      • Interactive Workshop SE Asia
      • Integrated Business Planning for Oil & Gas
    • Integ Bus Plng for Upstream Oil&Gas
    • S&OP for Upstream Supply Chains
    • Railcar Fleet Mgmt
    • Profit Optimization
    • Virtual Consultant
    • Nexview Online
  • Work
    • Approach
    • Clients & Industries
    • Case Studies
    • Operations Assessment
    • Change Implementation
  • Events
    • Next Public Course – Virtual S&OP
    • Executive Workshop
    • Conferences
  • Benchmarks
    • Key Topics in S&OP
    • Getting Sales Support for Demand Planning
    • Portfolio Review
    • How World Events Are Changing Supply Chains
  • Careers
  • Nexview Online
    • Clients login
    • Members
      • Login
      • Logout
      • My bookmarks
      • Update info
      • Member content archive
      • Bronze
    • Take a look/Join
    • Content archive
    • Blog
      • Sales & Operations Planning
      • Supply Chain Improvement
      • Supply Chain Results
      • Operations Assessment
      • Change Management
      • Organizational Effectiveness
    • Supply Chain Assessment Toolkits
      • Overview
      • S&OP
      • Demand Planning
      • Supply Planning
      • Procurement
      • IBP Upstream Oil & Gas
    • All eBooks
  • Contact

Implement S&OP First or Fix the Underlying Planning Processes First?

Key LeversThe short answer is yes. For organizations that don’t yet have S&OP, this is a question that usually gets asked since there are often recognized gaps in the underlying planning processes (e.g. product development/introduction, demand planning, inventory management, production planning, raw material planning, and financial planning). The point that gets raised is, “Shouldn’t we improve the foundational processes and inputs to S&OP first then we can attack it afterward?” Certainly a logical point, and if the gap in one or more input planning process is large, such as the company doesn’t even forecast, or have a way to roll-up a production plan across multiple facilities then the point becomes even stronger.

In most organizations, some level of planning is in place and although the processes can be improved upon, they can feed an S&OP process with a reasonable level of accuracy to get started. While you can launch S&OP in a few months, it will usually take several months to make it effective. If resources allow, the ideal condition is to work on S&OP and the underlying processes in parallel such as to continually improve the quality of information coming into the meetings. Hence the yes answer above. If resources don’t allow, and you choose to work S&OP first, it’s important to set the expectation with meeting owners and participants that S&OP will surface gaps in the input processes that will be prioritized and addressed when possible. The balance is to improve the feeder processes before the S&OP participants lose their patience.

While you can get away with some process gaps underneath S&OP, the deal killer is the inability to aggregate your planning data by product family over the required S&OP time horizon. If your systems do not let you go between aggregate and sku level detail easily, the required manual effort may be too time consuming to generate the necessary reports for the meetings. Please make sure this capability as well as the product and business hierarchy roll-up structure are in place before attempting S&OP.

Thus, maybe the answer to the question is, the consultant cop out answer of it depends. If your underlying processes are non-existent or have major gaps or you have the data roll-up gaps described above, address that first. If you can provide reasonable input data, set the right expectations with the participants, move forward with S&OP, and improve the underlying processes along the way.

You may also like

  • Five Ways to Excite Your Executive Team About S&OPFive Ways to Excite Your Executive Team About S&OP
  • Revitalize Your S&OP Process
  • Prepare Your Supply Chain Before the Hurricane StrikesPrepare Your Supply Chain Before the Hurricane Strikes
  • S&OP Readiness: 7 Components for Success and SustainabilityS&OP Readiness: 7 Components for Success and Sustainability
  • The Increasing Impact of Finance on S&OPThe Increasing Impact of Finance on S&OP
Share

Filed Under: Sales & Operations Planning

Tweets by @nexviewconsultg

Book – S&OP Results Tips, Traps, & Tools

Free eBook – Our Implementation Methodology

Featured Articles

  • "10 Tips for S&OP Sponsors" - APICS Magazine
  • Journal of Business Forecasting
  • Supply Chain Quarterly
  • Nexview Whitepaper
  • Journal of Trading Partner Practices
  • Nexview Overview Video
  • Nexview Online – Content Archive
  • Ideas – Blog Posts
  • Clients & Case Studies
  • IBP for Upstream Oil & Gas
  • S&OP and Supply Chain Training
  • S&OP Self Assessment Toolkit
  • Company Overview Flyer
  • Values
Share
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
follow us on LinkeIn
follow us on twitter


Copyright © 2023 · Nexview Consulting, LLC ®

X

Forgot Password?

Join Us

Password Reset
Please enter your e-mail address. You will receive a new password via e-mail.